WhoSampled Mobile App for iPhone and Android

Cover Version

0 Votes
Ahmad Zahir's Tanha Shodam Tanha
Lylee
Afghan Music 1977
Bimbo Jet's El Bimbo
Pathé Marconi EMI 1974

covered

Download this Track

Buy on Vinyl/CD

Main genre: World

Download this Track

Buy on Vinyl/CD

Producer: Laurent Rossi

Tags: Single

Main genre: Soul / Funk / Disco

Report wrong information or missing video
kreegah

Contributed by kreegah (2578 submissions)


Related Songs
see more Other covers of Bimbo Jet's El Bimbo:

Discussion
  • atolkachev
    atolkachev said 1 year ago:

    Thanks, indeed. The "conspiracy theory" about Zahir being the original author and Morgan is the plagiarizer undoubtedly stems from some web sites incorrectly listing the release date of "Lylee" as 1971. A typo or an incorrectly transcribed digit from some aged printed material, but it has born fanatical conviction in some. They are now looking for "proof" that Morgan wrote the song. I doubt that Mr. Ganem's letter to this site will convince them.

    Oh, and having denied the relevance of the Wikipedia article at first, they did eventually edit it to better mesh with their version of history.

  • walter
    walter said 2 years ago:

    An answer worth waiting for... thanks.

  • Spinks
    Spinks said 2 years ago:

    Claude Ganem (aka Claude Morgan), writer of 'El Bimbo', has written to us to clarify that he is the original writer of the song, which was released in 1974. Ahmad Zahir's version is a cover that was released in 1977. We've now fixed the page accordingly. Thanks Claude!

  • walter
    walter said 4 years ago:

    Yes, he does a few cover versions, that's why I'm so suspicious. Please don't report yet. I wouldn't mind leaving this song link as it is now, who knows someone might come along with the answer. Thanks.

  • kreegah
    kreegah said 4 years ago:

    That's a fair point you're raising. Did try to obtain some actual proof - but none was readily available. It seems Zahir did do quite a bit of cover versions, so it might very well be the other way round too.

    Bimbo Jet's Wiki page does give Tanha Shodam Tanha as the original version, but still I'm starting to think I was too hasty with this one. If I won't be able to find any solid proof, I'll report it tomorrow.

  • walter
    walter said 4 years ago:

    Okay, this was rumoured for years on the internet and it is very plausible, I admit. BUT is there actual proof? Like a release year on a Zahir label or record sleeve. Isn't it strange that Zahir's wiki page doesn't even mention this song?